SIGN UP

COMPANY INFORMATION
Company Name*
Website
Email ID
Phone
Company Address*
Company State*
Company City*
Pin Code*
 I agree to the Terms and Conditions.
captcha image
< BACK       

Australian Thermal Coal Leaves Investors Cold

Share:            
news
Source: Bloomberg, July 13, 2019

When you’re in the business of buying and selling, timing is everything.



That’s the costly lesson facing BHP Group, which is looking at options to divest its thermal coal assets according to a report Thursday by Thomas Biesheuvel of Bloomberg News that cited people familiar with the matter.



Peas in a Pod
Ebitda at the coal mines BHP may sell is similar to that at the Australian mines Rio Tinto sold in 2016



Arch-rival Rio Tinto Group raised $2.7 billion selling mines in the Hunter Valley north of Sydney to Yancoal Australia Ltd., in a process that started in 2016. BHP could get far less: Macquarie Group Ltd. estimates $1.6 billion. That’s despite the fact that BHP’s Mount Arthur and Cerrejon mines, in the Hunter Valley and Colombia, post roughly the same Ebitda as as the ones Rio Tinto sold. 



BHP has had good reasons to keep operating these mines. They’ve produced several years of good earnings, for one. Mount Arthur has probably been even more profitable than it looks on paper, thanks to its ability to utilize tax losses that will now be running low.



Curve Ball
The futures curve for high-ranking Australian energy coal is markedly higher now than it was when Rio Tinto sold its local coal assets



Still, it will be galling to sell at a discount when the long-term price for the high-energy coal mined in the Hunter Valley is now about a third higher than the $63 a metric ton level at the time Rio Tinto’s deal was announced.



What’s changed? More or less everything.



Back in 2016, coal was still the lowest-cost way of delivering new generation in most major markets. The slumping price of wind and solar generation since then has changed the game. Thermal coal will fall to 11% of U.S. generation by 2030 from the mid-20s at present, S&P Global Ratings wrote in a report Wednesday; outside of Spain and Germany, most European coal-fired plants will be retired by 2025.



Rising Sun
The price of new solar generation is below the price of new coal in most major markets



North Asian markets supplied by Mount Arthur look like an exception, with Japan, South Korea and China making up about 80% of Australia’s thermal coal exports. The first two countries are rare cases where falling renewables costs have failed to undercut the black stuff.



Even there, though, the picture is dimming: Japan’s coal-fired capacity will go into to decline starting 2023, and actual demand should fall faster since its most recent plants use fuel more efficiently, according to a report this week by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, a research group opposed to fossil fuels. South Korea now has taxes on coal amounting to $60 a ton and imports will fall by half by 2040, according to the International Energy Agency.



The group of potential buyers looks thin, too. Anglo American Plc, which has a one-third stake in Cerrejon alongside BHP and Glencore Plc, doesn’t seem in the mood for bulking up. The Japanese trading houses that have historically been major investors in Australia’s mining industry, meanwhile, have been quietly divesting strategic coal stakes for several years. 



Southern Oscillation
Glencore could make its coal operations more profitable without increasing output by selling South African mines and buying Australian ones



What does that leave? Glencore, despite a promise in February to cap coal output, shouldn't be ignored. In that announcement, the commodities trader noted it may still buy out some minority stakes, which seems to anticipate a deal on Cerrejon. Glencore could also, in theory, get rid of its South African operations and replace them with Mount Arthur, keeping total output within limits and swapping in a more profitable mine. That would depend on finding a buyer for those South African mines, though, and there’s enough turmoil in that country’s coal and energy sector as it is.



China is another possible buyer for Mount Arthur. The pit is adjacent to Yancoal’s existing operations, suggesting possible synergies. Still, 2019 isn’t the best year to be doing this. Since February, the country has been holding up shipments of Australian coal for ill-defined reasons that have a whiff of geopolitics about them. Any Chinese business looking for government approval to buy an Australian coal mine will have to reckon with that.



Beyond that, there’s even the possibility that smaller local miners will have a go. In the old days, the idea that a relative minnow like Whitehaven Coal Ltd. could absorb a pit the size of Mount Arthur would have seemed absurd, but at Macquarie’s estimate of a $600 million price tag it’s not impossible. Based on BHP’s latest results, a buyer could pay off that sum in 18 months or so and run the mine for cash, assuming rehabilitation costs weren’t too high. 



Still, how times have changed. Back when Rio Tinto was hawking its coal assets, the company could plausibly argue that it still saw a bright future for the stuff. Nowadays, BHP is warning that it could be “phased out, potentially sooner than expected,” even as it’s trying to tempt buyers. Those M&A bankers are going to have their work cut out to get a good price.

News Source: Bloomberg

Vietnam boosts Russian coal imports

Adani refuses to commit to size of 'scaled-down' C...

Indonesia sets May HBA thermal coal price at $81.8...

Adani Expects India Coal Imports to Surge to a Rec...

Adani expects India's coal imports to surge to a r...

Poland to hold talks on Prairie Mining coal projec...

Adani's coal project in Australia may take off as...

BHP sees early end for thermal coal, plugs in to e...

Column: Adani's coal hopes look increasingly isola...

India’s SCCL developing greenfield underground coa...

Two reported Central Appalachia thermal coal deals...

Regulators set date for Adani mine approvals

India’s coal import rises 13% in April 2019

ICI 4 thermal coal derivatives prices hold steady

Indian govt projects sharp drop in thermal coal im...

Indian govt projects sharp drop in thermal coal im...

India to maintain its level of thermal coal import...

Destination of South32’s SA thermal coal assets ma...

China, India thermal coal imports hit multi-year h...

June ICI 4 coal contracts steady, physical trade m...

India to maintain its level of thermal coal import...

Germany’s interest in Russian coal rises

ICI 4 coal derivatives market begins to stabilise

Australia's standing in Pacific has plummeted beca...

Coal India to hire merchant bankers for acquiring...

UPDATE 1-China's May coal imports climb 8.6% from...

Polish coal unions to protest against planned dism...

China’s May coal imports climb 8.6% from month bef...

Vietnam's May coal imports rise 57% on year to 3.8...

Column: Coal price slump in Asia even as demand gr...

ICI 4 coal derivatives trade at higher price

Nippon Steel settles 2Q semi-soft coking coal at $...

Vietnam’s May coal imports rise 57% on year to 3.8...

China’s raw coal production up 3.5 pc in May

Myths and reality: Adani’s Australian coal mine to...

Coal producer Cambrian files for Ch. 11 as thermal...

China's benchmark power coal price remains flat

Bumi Resources expects to sell 42 million tons of...

China's Fuzhou port tightens coal import restricti...

China's import thermal coal market remains tense f...

China's May thermal coal import rises 35% on year...

Coal market faces 25mt overhang in 2019 – analyst

Noble Group sees lower coal prices for next few ye...

April-May thermal coal volumes at key Indian ports...

Canada, US gain as India cuts dependence on Austra...

April-May thermal coal volumes at key Indian ports...

Platts to launch European Blended Price thermal co...

Asia’s coal developers feeling left out by cold sh...

Japanese thermal coal buyers try out Newcastle HA...

Tighter Chinese coal import controls add to Guangx...

Built for a boom, Glencore gets banged up

Downside risk remains for coal in July amid oversu...

Australia sees gold overtaking thermal coal as exp...

Aussie trade surplus hits record $5.7bn

US May coal exports total 8.24 million mt, down 5....

Chinese thermal coal demand to fall with launch of...

Indonesia sets Jul HBA thermal coal price at $71.9...

Thailand boosts imports of Russian coal

Russia-Ukraine conflict sees coal deliveries drop...

Chinese thermal coal demand to fall with launch of...

China Learns an Iron Law of Markets

Questions raised after Australia coal mine deaths

BHP Is Latest Giant Miner to Plan Exit From Therma...

Colombian May thermal coal exports up 32.3%: DANE

BHP Is Latest Giant Miner to Plan Exit From Therma...

King coal rules in Japan as power utilities in thr...

Prices rise slightly for 3Q ICI 4 coal derivatives

China’s Australian coking coal imports double in M...

Newcastle coal edges lower amid softening demand

Newcastle coal resumes slide amid rising trade ten...

June ICI 4 coal derivatives clear at softer price

China's port controls for Australian thermal coal...

China imports of US coking coal rise five-fold in...

Newcastle coal slumps to 2-year low as trade jitte...

Indonesian physical coal prices hold steady

Newcastle coal slips to 3-year low

Wallarah 2 thermal coal project takes leap forward...

Indonesian physical coal prices hold steady

Lower for longer: Supply glut in focus as Asia’s b...

ICI 4 coal derivatives trade picks up

Newcastle coal prices hover near 3-year lows

China Coal Imports Seen Cooling Once Beijing Reins...

Australia coal exports to Europe rise in May

Analysts revise 2019 coal price outlook down nearl...

Low-CV Indonesian coal prices steady to softer

Share: